13 Pop-Tart Flavors Ranked Worst To Best

13. Chocolatey chip pancake

The Chocolatey Chip Pancake flavor combines chocolate with hints of maple syrup. The Pop-Tart features chocolate chips both inside and on top. We anticipated a more pronounced chocolate flavor, but the maple syrup dominates instead. While maple syrup can enhance the taste of various dishes, from eggnog to egg salad, in this Pop-Tart, it was overwhelming—even for our kids, who usually love sweet treats. Each pack contains two tarts, totaling 390 calories and 30 grams of sugar, which is the highest calorie count but surprisingly lower in sugar compared to many other Pop-Tarts. We only found this unique flavor at one store, packaged in a small box containing four packs, with two tarts in each.

If there were a better balance between the rich chocolate and syrup flavors, we might have enjoyed these more. As they stand, however, they ranked at the bottom of our list. Given their limited availability, we can confidently say we are unlikely to purchase them again.

12. Strawberry milkshake

The Frosted Strawberry Milkshake caught the attention of our daughter, who adores pink and is a big fan of sprinkles adorning the Pop-Tart. Unfortunately, the charming pink pastry didn't quite meet our expectations, which was our main concern with this flavor. The filling was creamy, unlike the strawberry version that has a jelly-like consistency, but we felt it lacked the full range of milkshake flavors, offering only a creamy strawberry taste.

While it was enjoyable, it didn't stand out, placing it near the bottom of our rankings. Generally, we prefer jelly fillings over the creamy ones found in the strawberry milkshake. We did appreciate that this flavor contained less sugar than many others, with only 28 grams per serving. Given its sweet inspiration, this was unexpected, but the difference wasn't significant enough to make us want to choose it again. We only found it at one store, and it only comes in a smaller box, so we likely wouldn't go out of our way to buy it again.

11. Frosted wild berry

The Wild Berry Pop-Tart offers a delightful blend of strawberry, cherry, and raspberry flavors. If you're torn between fruit options, this pastry is a great pick as it encompasses them all. While the vibrant blue and purple frosting is a bit of a mystery, it certainly didn't deter our kids from grabbing these treats. However, the adults were less enthusiastic, which contributed to this flavor ranking lower on our list. Pop-Tarts aren't typically known for their natural appeal, and the bright blue hue was somewhat off-putting. Additionally, the frosting was a bit crumbly, and the sight of blue sugar flakes falling onto our plates didn't enhance the pastry's appeal.

With 31 grams of sugar, this Pop-Tart falls in the middle range for added sugar content. We appreciated the flavor and found it to be a reasonable choice in terms of sugar, but the overly colorful frosting was a bit distracting. The kids also seemed less thrilled about this option, especially with so many chocolate and fudge varieties available nearby.

10. Frosted hot fudge sundae

If you're in the mood for dessert at breakfast, the Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae flavor is the way to go, but brace yourself for a sugar overload. This option was quite sweet, and the creamy filling was particularly memorable, especially when compared to some of the other flavors we sampled. The chocolate shell complemented the frosting, sprinkles, and extra drizzle on top nicely. While we enjoyed each component individually, the overall sweetness was overwhelming, even with just one pastry. Each element would make a great addition to a Pop-Tart on its own, but together, it felt like too much.

On the plus side, the Pop-Tart version is more convenient than ice cream and incorporates all the classic sundae elements: a creamy ice cream-inspired filling, a crispy chocolate shell, vibrant sprinkles, and a drizzle of hard fudge. Our kids were bigger fans of this Pop-Tart than we were, but even they couldn't finish the two-pack. Each serving contains 370 calories and 32 grams of sugar.

9. Frosted cookies and crème

The Frosted Cookies and Crème Pop-Tart features a chocolate exterior topped with frosting. We anticipated it to be excessively sweet, but the decadent chocolate pastry effectively balanced the whipped cream-inspired filling and topping. Additionally, it was adorned with chocolate cookie bits, which contributed extra texture compared to some other varieties. While we’re reluctant to label a Pop-Tart as complex, this flavor offered more intrigue than the rest, securing a higher ranking on our list than we initially expected.

Each pack contains two Pop-Tarts with a total of 36 grams of added sugar, the highest among all the options. This isn’t surprising considering the sweetness of the filling, though the chocolate outer layer provided some contrast. It remained quite sweet, so we’d likely opt for just one if we decided to treat ourselves to this flavor.

8. Frosted blueberry

We often find ourselves drawn to the fruit-flavored Pop-Tarts, as the jam-like filling inside offers a pleasantly tart taste. The Frosted Blueberry variety is both rich and sweet, boasting a robust berry flavor. The exterior is adorned with colorful sugary bits, including blue, which helps distinguish this flavor from other fruit Pop-Tarts when they’re all mixed together. While it doesn’t alter the flavor, it certainly makes it easier to spot this particular option.

One drawback of this variety is that the jelly filling can be messy and may leave stains. Nevertheless, the taste is delightful and sweet, making it a choice we would happily select again. You can find the blueberry flavor alongside frosted strawberry and cherry in a variety pack at certain stores. This is a great way to introduce some diversity into your Pop-Tart selection with just one purchase, accommodating different preferences within your family. The blueberry version contains 30 grams of added sugar, which is consistent with other fruit flavors.

7. Frosted chocolate fudge

This Pop-Tart flavor is all about chocolate. The Frosted Chocolate Fudge pastry features a rich fudge filling encased in a chocolate shell, topped with chocolate frosting. It's incredibly sweet and indulgent, perfect for satisfying your sweet cravings. We appreciated the subtle contrast between the chocolate exterior and the fudge interior, although it was only noticeable when we really focused on each bite.

If you're sharing this treat with young kids, be prepared for some messy hands and faces. A quick cleanup is usually necessary after enjoying the chocolate fudge. You might also consider separating the two Pop-Tarts in a pack to avoid an overwhelming sugar rush. This flavor quickly became a favorite among our kids, even surpassing some of the options we adults preferred. Each pack contains 32 grams of added sugar, which was less than we anticipated given the flavor, but still a significant amount for breakfast.

6. Unfrosted strawberry

Pop-Tarts may not offer a wide variety of unfrosted flavors, but the classic strawberry option stands out as a great choice. It topped our list among adults, who favored it over the more sugary alternatives. Interestingly, it contains 25 grams of added sugar, which is relatively low for a Pop-Tart but still higher than many other breakfast items.

Think of it as a sweeter take on toast and jam, especially when you warm it up in the toaster. If you're craving a bit more sweetness, you can always add your own frosting or powdered sugar on top. For special birthday breakfasts, we love to drizzle some hot fudge and sprinkle on our own decorations, allowing for personalized designs and festive messages.

As it is, this flavor is our preferred option for on-the-go eating. It’s less messy than those topped with icing or sprinkles and tends to hold together better, resulting in fewer crumbs (though there are still a few).

5. Frosted strawberry

The Frosted Strawberry Pop-Tart edged out its unfrosted counterpart due to its broader appeal within our household. While it shares the same jelly filling, it features a crunchy frosting layer and vibrant sprinkles on top. The sugary sprinkles lack blue, which is the only distinction between this flavor and the Frosted Blueberry variant, aside from the filling. You can find it alongside blueberry and cherry options in a variety pack or purchase it in small or large boxes. Each two-Pop-Tart pack contains 30 grams of added sugar.

This flavor is among the easiest to find, earning it high praise from us. We appreciate Pop-Tarts for their convenience, so being able to locate them at various stores without needing special trips is essential. The Frosted Strawberry flavor is delicious whether enjoyed hot or cold and has a wide appeal. If this Pop-Tart were to attend a high school reunion, it would likely be voted "most likely to remain popular with the majority of the class."

4. Frosted banana bread

We were pleasantly surprised by how much we enjoyed the Frosted Banana Bread Pop-Tart. From the very first bite, it offered a delightful combination of sweetness and warm spices. The pastry shell resembles a graham cracker, perfectly complementing the banana filling, while the exterior is topped with banana-flavored frosting. We're not entirely sure how Pop-Tart achieved this, but it truly tastes just like the sweet banana bread we make at home. Toast it, and you'll be treated to a wonderful aroma filling your kitchen, along with its delicious flavor. Each two-tart pack contains 34 grams of sugar for those looking for a little extra sweetness.

Finding the Banana Bread flavor can be a bit of a challenge, but the well-balanced taste of sweet and rich makes it worthwhile. We only spotted it at a few stores, and then only in the small box containing four packs. This is the only unique flavor that we would actively seek out.

3. Frosted s'mores

If you're in the mood for the delightful blend of graham cracker, chocolate, and marshmallow that defines s'mores, we strongly suggest trying the S'mores Pop-Tarts. They stand out as the only variety we discovered with a dual-flavor filling, which is one reason they ranked so highly on our list. The other reason is their flavor, which perfectly captures the essence of a s'more and appeals to both children and adults alike. Inside these Pop-Tarts, you'll find marshmallows and chocolate, while the pastry shell adds a hint of spiced graham cracker flavor along with chocolate frosting. Each pack contains 33 grams of added sugar, making it one of the higher sugar options on our list, but it aligns with the other dessert-inspired flavors.

These Pop-Tarts are especially popular among young fans, who enjoy the idea of having dessert for breakfast. When given a choice between this flavor and other dessert-themed options like Cookies & Crème and Hot Fudge Sundae, the S'mores variety ultimately emerged as the favorite. While the others garnered initial interest, the S'mores Pop-Tart was the only one that was devoured down to the last crumb.

2. Frosted brown sugar cinnamon

For a Pop-Tart that offers a bit more warmth and richness, consider the Brown Sugar Cinnamon flavor. It features a smooth frosting on top rather than the usual sprinkles. The filling strikes a balance between jelly and frosting, packed with sugar and cinnamon. Each package contains 30 grams of sugar, comparable to other favorites like Frosted Strawberry.

This flavor was our top choice when enjoyed heated. While it's decent at room temperature, it truly shines when toasted. A quick trip through the toaster on a medium setting warms the filling and enhances the flavor to make it utterly delightful. Although it requires a bit of extra time, we assure you it's worth it. You can easily find this flavor at grocery stores, including budget-friendly options like Aldi, where you can save a bit on a pack of 12 pastries. It was a close call between this and the S'mores flavor for the second spot in our rankings, but the warm cinnamon flavor gave this one a slight advantage.

1. Frosted cherry

A long-standing favorite in our family is the Frosted Cherry Pop-Tart flavor. It captures the delightful tartness and sweetness of cherry pie, complemented by a subtle crunch from the sugar bits sprinkled on the frosting. In contrast to the Frosted Strawberry and Blueberry varieties, this frosting is a soft pink adorned with reddish-pink sugar crystals. Like the other fruit flavors, it contains 30 grams of added sugar and is offered in small, large, or variety packs.

While most Pop-Tarts are sweet, the tart cherry jelly filling provides a better balance, making it appealing to both adults and children. This tartness is a distinctive feature of the cherry flavor, which has earned it the prestigious top position in our rankings. Even when we conducted side-by-side taste tests with various Pop-Tart flavors, this one consistently came out on top. It’s like enjoying a portable cherry pie for breakfast, and it tastes fantastic whether served cold or warm.

Methodology

We sampled all the Pop-Tart flavors side-by-side to determine which ones were the most delicious. We evaluated the flavor of the pastry itself, along with the toppings and ease of transport. Some flavors were more difficult to find in stores, which made us less inclined to seek them out, particularly if they weren't at the top of our flavor preferences. Thankfully, many of our favorites are also popular among customers and are readily available on the shelves of various grocery stores, often sold in larger packs. While the novelty flavors were entertaining, they weren't always varieties we would actively pursue.

Pop-Tarts are generally high in sugar, a factor we took into account in our rankings. Although we wouldn't label these breakfast treats as healthy, some flavors contained less sugar than others. Our top picks ended up being those with a unique twist, whether it was a dual-flavor filling, warm spices, or a tangy taste. The Pop-Tarts that truly stood out captured our attention and made us eager for another bite.