Before Making Ina Garten's Key Lime Pie, Make Sure You Have The Right Equipment

Preparing Ina Garten's Key Lime Pie requires attention to detail and the right equipment to ensure the best results. First, a quality pie pan is essential for shaping the crust, preferably a nine-inch one, which allows the graham cracker crust to form a sturdy base. A food processor can be invaluable for crushing the graham crackers and blending them with sugar and melted butter, creating a well-mixed, even consistency. A hand-held or stand mixer is crucial for whisking the egg yolks and condensed milk together, achieving the smooth, creamy texture that defines a good key lime pie filling. Freshly squeezed key lime juice is a must, so a reliable citrus juicer will help extract the juice efficiently from the tiny limes. A fine grater or microplane is useful for zesting the limes, adding a burst of citrus flavor to the mix. When baking the pie, an oven thermometer can help maintain the correct baking temperature, ensuring that the filling sets properly without overcooking. Lastly, a cooling rack is helpful for allowing the pie to cool evenly after baking. With these tools at hand, you'll be well-equipped to make Ina Garten's delicious key lime pie with confidence.
Advertisement

More ways to iterate on the Barefoot Contessa's key lime pie

With a fairly straightforward recipe that comes together quickly, there’s plenty of opportunity to put your own spin on the traditional key lime pie. Consider incorporating one of these unexpected ingredients: yogurt, milk powder, or white chocolate. By replacing some of the sweetened condensed milk with plain yogurt, you’ll achieve a slightly tangier flavor (sour cream can also be a great alternative in small amounts). Just make sure not to prepare the pie filling too far ahead of time.

Incorporating milk powder into the graham cracker crust enhances its sweetness without altering the texture. Meanwhile, Milk Bar founder Christina Tosi suggests a more adventurous approach with white chocolate—apply a thin layer of it to the inside of the crust. This addition not only provides a refreshing flavor that pairs beautifully with the citrus but also reinforces the crust’s structure, allowing for clean, even slices. For a finishing touch, take a cue from Publix by sprinkling the top of your pie with lightly toasted, slivered almonds before serving.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement