Costco's 5-Pound Mixed Berry Cheesecake Comes With An Equally Hefty Price Tag

Is the fruity cheesecake worth it? Members have mixed feelings

Costco is famous for its fantastic bargains, making it difficult for some to justify spending over $20 on a dessert, even a large one. Many of the bakery's other offerings are more budget-friendly, like the key lime pie priced at $15.99. However, when compared to Costco's standard cheesecake, which weighs 4.5 pounds, costs around $24, and is considered one of the bakery's more basic options due to its simplicity, the nearly 6-pound mixed berry cheesecake stands out as a flavorful deal. For just about a dollar less, you get over an extra pound of creamy delight. Plus, while the plain cheesecake comes pre-sliced into 16 servings, the berry version does not, allowing you to potentially get a few more slices while still saving a dollar.

The slight tartness of the fruity cheesecake may attract some customers, especially since many of Costco's other desserts are quite rich. In a Reddit discussion about the dessert, one user noted, "The mixed berry topping was more tart than I expected. It's not overly sweet, which is nice." Another user praised it highly: "Best non-chocolate cheesecake I've ever had. My wife ranked it in her top five, and she's a cheesecake expert." However, opinions may vary, as one user remarked, "I was the only one in our house who thought it was okay, and it felt pricey." Ultimately, the best way to determine if you'll enjoy the mixed berry cheesecake is to give it a try yourself.

Want something sweeter? Try these other Costco desserts

Costco's bakery is always busy producing a variety of desserts, but not all of them are equally appealing. Take the mixed berry cheesecake, for instance; while it may remind some of the popular Costco four berry pie, it may not suit everyone's taste. If you enjoy a tangy dessert, this one might be right up your alley. However, if you lean towards larger, sweeter treats, there are plenty of other options to consider while you're at the warehouse.

Looking for a massive pie that's rich and indulgent? For $19.99, you can grab Costco's chocolate peanut butter pie, which beautifully merges two beloved flavors into one delightful dessert. Weighing in at nearly 5 pounds, it’s an excellent choice for potlucks and gatherings. If you want something equally creamy and sweet, Costco's banana cream pie is available for just $15.99 and weighs almost 3 ½ pounds. You can even freeze a slice for a refreshing summer snack.

If you’re after a dessert similar to the mixed berry cheesecake but with a more straightforward flavor profile, consider Costco's cherry cheesecake. Priced at $22.99, it features the same cherries found in the bakery's popular Danishes, which are among the store's most cherished treats. So, whether you're a berry lover or not, Costco has a dessert to satisfy every craving — no matter what you're in the mood for.