master-cooks | Expert Tips For Crafting A Better Old Fashioned

Crafting a superior Old Fashioned involves attention to detail and a respect for tradition, while also allowing for personal flair. Begin with a high-quality bourbon or rye whiskey, as the spirit forms the backbone of this classic cocktail. Opt for a whiskey with a smooth profile, yet robust enough to stand up to the other ingredients. The sugar cube, traditionally muddled with bitters, can be replaced with simple syrup for a smoother texture. Experiment with different bitters, such as orange or aromatic, to add depth and complexity. The choice of ice is crucial; large cubes or spheres are preferable as they melt slowly, preventing dilution. A twist of orange or lemon peel adds a citrusy aroma, enhancing the drink’s sensory appeal. Fresh is best, so use a sharp knife to cut a wide strip of peel, avoiding the bitter pith. Stir the drink gently to ensure proper integration of flavors. Finally, consider experimenting with subtle additions like a dash of maple syrup or a hint of smoked salt to put a unique spin on the classic recipe. An Old Fashioned is as much about the ritual as it is about the drink itself, inviting you to savor each sip.

Quality ingredients come first for an expertly made old fashioned

A helpful guideline is that a shorter ingredient list often indicates higher quality components. This is especially true for a cocktail that is alcohol-forward and meant for slow sipping; a premium bourbon, whiskey, or rye whiskey is crucial. "The spirit is the highlight, so select one that aligns with your preferences," advises Justin Lavenue. "I suggest opting for a slightly higher-proof bourbon or rye whiskey to ensure it retains its richness and character when mixed with the other ingredients."

The next key component is the sweetener. Traditionally, an old fashioned uses a sugar cube or a teaspoon of sugar muddled with a bit of water at the bottom of the glass. However, Lavenue recommends using demerara simple syrup instead. When you muddle sugar, it continues to dissolve as you enjoy your drink, resulting in each sip becoming sweeter. Simple syrup, on the other hand, provides a consistent sweetness throughout your drink.

Finally, the best bartenders know not to overdo the bitters. "I believe four dashes is ideal," says Lavenue. "It's all about achieving balance — each ingredient should enhance, not overshadow, the others." With these expert insights, you're all set to create an old fashioned cocktail like a professional.

Expert Tips For Crafting A Better Old Fashioned

Quality ingredients come first for an expertly made old fashioned

Recommended

Next up