How Many Apples Does It Take To Make An Apple Pie?

Creating an apple pie requires a thoughtful selection of apples, both in terms of quantity and variety, to achieve the perfect balance of flavor, texture, and sweetness. Typically, a standard nine-inch apple pie demands about six to eight medium-sized apples. This amount can vary slightly based on the depth of the pie dish and personal preference for filling thickness. The choice of apple varieties is equally important, with many bakers opting for a mix to enhance the pie’s complexity. Common choices include Granny Smith for their tartness and firmness, Honeycrisp for their sweetness and juiciness, and Braeburn or Golden Delicious for their balanced flavor profile. The combination of these apples contributes to a dynamic taste, ensuring that the pie is neither too sweet nor too tart. It's essential to peel, core, and slice the apples uniformly to promote even cooking and avoid any undesirable textures in the finished pie. Additionally, seasoning the apples with a blend of sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and a hint of lemon juice can enhance their natural flavors. The result is a delightful, aromatic apple pie that captures the essence of the season and satisfies the palate.
Advertisement

Picking apple types and other apple-lutely necessary pie tips

If you're aiming for six to eight apples for the ideal pie, hold off before you leave the store with a bag full of Granny Smiths. Pie connoisseurs actually suggest using a mix of apple varieties to enhance the classic dessert's flavor profile. While Granny Smith apples can be included, consider adding Golden Delicious, Honeycrisp, Braeburn, or Macintosh as well. The goal is to combine sweet and tart apples, so select two to three apples from several different types.

The method you use to prepare your filling can also help you determine the right number of apples. Pre-cooking your pie filling allows the apples to release some moisture before they go into the crust, making it easier to gauge how full to fill your pie without the uncertainty you might otherwise face. This technique can also help avoid a soggy pie. While you're reducing your apples, Paul Hollywood recommends blind baking your crust beforehand to achieve the crispiest result.

If you prefer apple crisp, you'll need the same quantity of apples. The only distinction between apple crisp and apple pie lies in the topping.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement