master-cooks | How The Sandwich Gained And Lost Its Scandalous Reputation

The sandwich, a staple in culinary culture, has an intriguing history marked by scandal and redemption. Originating in the 18th century, it is said to owe its name to John Montagu, the 4th Earl of Sandwich. The story goes that Montagu, an avid gambler, requested his meat be served between slices of bread so he could eat without leaving the gaming table. This association with gambling, a morally questionable activity at the time, gave the sandwich a dubious reputation. Initially considered a food of convenience for dubious characters, it was often linked to vice and indulgence. As the Industrial Revolution progressed, the working class began to adopt the sandwich as a practical, portable meal. Its convenience and versatility made it appealing to laborers who needed sustenance without a formal meal break. This shift helped to rehabilitate its image, transforming it from a symbol of excess to one of practicality and efficiency. Over time, the sandwich evolved into a beloved food item across various cultures, celebrated for its adaptability and ease of preparation. Today, it is a culinary icon, enjoyed by people of all ages and backgrounds, far removed from its once scandalous beginnings.

Sandwiches' association with vice and greed

Contrary to popular belief, some historians suggest that Montagu likely requested this simple, portable meal while diligently working at his desk, rather than during an all-night gaming session. While Montagu did enjoy card games and gambling like many gentlemen of his era, he was equally dedicated to his political career. Therefore, it seems improbable that he would have been so reckless with his time or finances as to gamble for an entire day. So, where did these stories originate?

The original legend appears to stem from French writer Pierre-Jean Grosley's observations during his time in England, documented in his book "A Tour of London." Although historians consider the tale to be exaggerated, it highlights the connection between sandwiches and gambling, as well as men's activities during Montagu's era. Gambling was a favored pastime in the 18th century, likely due to advancements in industry and trade that enabled working-class men to ascend the social ladder.

While women did occasionally partake in gambling, it typically occurred in the privacy of homes, as gaming establishments were exclusively for men. These disreputable, smoky venues were regarded as dens of vice and potential financial disaster. Within these spaces, men could — and often did — squander fortunes, leading their families into poverty. The frequent serving of sandwiches in these establishments further linked them to men's vices and irresponsible conduct.

Saving the sandwich from an unseemly reputation

Despite its humble origins, the sandwich quickly became popular beyond men's gatherings due to its convenience and adaptability. Social events among the elite often concluded with a light evening meal, and sandwiches soon became a common feature at supper tables. Not long after, George III and Queen Charlotte further established the sandwich's status in respectable society by bringing them along on outings to feed their 15 children while on the move.

By this time, the sandwich had transformed from a simple layer of cold beef or ham between two slices of bread into something more sophisticated. Home cooks were encouraged to incorporate flavors and ingredients suitable for elegant social occasions. This shift led to the creation of delicate tea sandwiches filled with thinly sliced cucumber, cress, and fresh butter, or savory cheese and pickles.

At the same time, sandwiches were also becoming popular among the working class. Men working in mills and factories often found themselves too far from home to enjoy a midday meal with their families. Instead, they would bring sandwiches to work to keep them fueled throughout the day. As a result, the sandwich gained traction across Europe and into North America, becoming a staple in both households and restaurants. Once rescued from its less-than-glamorous beginnings, the sandwich has now become an integral part of modern culture — and a delicious one at that.

How The Sandwich Gained And Lost Its Scandalous Reputation

Sandwiches' association with vice and greed

Saving the sandwich from an unseemly reputation

Recommended

Next up