Ina Garten's Popular Mac And Cheese Has One Unexpected Step You'll Need To Plan Ahead For

Ina Garten's famous mac and cheese, renowned for its rich, decadent flavor, includes a surprising twist: a crucial make-ahead step. Before baking, Garten prepares a béchamel sauce, then cools it completely. This pre-chilling allows the sauce to thicken perfectly, creating an ultra-creamy base that sets her recipe apart. This simple yet vital preparation ensures a flawlessly smooth and luxurious mac and cheese, making it a must-try for any comfort food enthusiast.
Advertisement

A Classic Comfort Food, Elevated: Ina Garten's Mac and Cheese

Ina Garten, the beloved Barefoot Contessa, is known for her approachable yet sophisticated recipes that consistently deliver delicious results. Among her many culinary triumphs, her macaroni and cheese stands out as a particularly popular and comforting dish. It's not just your average mac and cheese; Garten elevates this classic with rich flavors and a creamy texture that's simply irresistible. While the ingredients are relatively straightforward – cheese, pasta, and a béchamel sauce – there's one specific step in her recipe that might surprise you and definitely requires a bit of foresight: chilling the béchamel sauce. This isn't a last-minute throw-together meal; Ina's mac and cheese requires a touch of planning to achieve its ultimate cheesy perfection.

The Secret's in the Sauce...and the Chill

The unexpected step that sets Ina Garten's mac and cheese apart is the instruction to chill the béchamel sauce completely before assembling and baking the dish.  Most mac and cheese recipes involve pouring a freshly made, warm béchamel sauce directly over the cooked pasta and cheese before baking. However, Garten’s recipe takes a different approach. After creating the velvety béchamel base with butter, flour, milk, and nutmeg, and stirring in a generous amount of Gruyère and sharp cheddar cheese, the recipe explicitly states to “chill the cheese sauce until it is cold.” This isn't a minor suggestion; it’s a crucial part of achieving the desired outcome.

Advertisement

Why Cold Sauce is Key: Plan Ahead for Perfection

But why chill the sauce? The reason behind this seemingly unusual step is texture and overall richness. Chilling the béchamel allows it to thicken significantly. When warm, the sauce is fluid, but as it cools, the butterfat and starch solidify, creating a much denser and more luxurious consistency. This thickened, cold cheese sauce then evenly coats the pasta when assembled, preventing the sauce from becoming thin or watery during baking.  It ensures every elbow macaroni is enveloped in a rich, cheesy blanket.  Therefore, this chilling step is not just a random instruction; it's a carefully considered technique to enhance the final texture and ensure a supremely decadent mac and cheese.

Easy to Execute: Incorporating the Chilling Step

Planning for this chilling stage is surprisingly simple. After you’ve made the béchamel sauce and incorporated the cheeses, just transfer it to a bowl, cover it with plastic wrap pressed directly onto the surface to prevent a skin from forming, and refrigerate.  The recipe typically recommends chilling for at least a few hours, or even overnight. This makes it incredibly convenient for make-ahead cooking. You can prepare the cheese sauce a day in advance, leaving you with only the pasta cooking and assembly steps to handle closer to mealtime.  Once chilled, the sauce will be quite thick, almost like a spreadable cheese dip. Don't be alarmed – this is exactly the texture you want for Ina Garten's truly exceptional mac and cheese.

Advertisement

Worth the Wait: Mac and Cheese Nirvana

While the chilling step might require a little extra planning, the payoff is undeniably worth it. Ina Garten's mac and cheese transcends the ordinary. The chilled béchamel ensures a final dish that’s incredibly creamy, intensely cheesy, and perfectly textured. The planning ahead aspect, while unexpected, becomes an integral part of what makes this mac and cheese so special. It's a testament to Ina Garten's thoughtful approach to cooking – taking a familiar comfort food and elevating it to something truly extraordinary with a single, smart technique. So, next time you crave a truly exceptional mac and cheese, remember Ina's secret: chill out, plan ahead, and prepare for mac and cheese nirvana.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement