master-cooks | Is Bottled Water Really Just Repackaged Tap Water?

The debate over whether bottled water is merely repackaged tap water has garnered attention for years. Many bottled water brands source their product from municipal supplies, which means that the origin of the water is indeed the same as tap water. However, the key difference lies in the treatment and filtration processes that bottled water undergoes, which often exceed those used for tap water. These processes can include additional filtration, reverse osmosis, and other purification methods to remove impurities and enhance taste. Furthermore, some bottled waters are sourced from natural springs, artesian wells, or other protected sources, which can offer a different mineral composition compared to municipal water supplies. Regulatory standards for bottled water can vary from country to country, but in many places, they are similar to or even stricter than those for tap water. Despite this, environmental concerns about the production and disposal of plastic bottles, as well as the significant markup on bottled water, have led some critics to argue that it is an unnecessary commodity. Ultimately, the choice between tap and bottled water often comes down to personal preference, perceived quality, and convenience, but it is important for consumers to be informed about the source and treatment of the water they choose to drink.

What's in your water?

It's important to recognize that bottled water producers frequently add substances to enhance the flavor of their products. For instance, LIFEWTR, which we identified as the top-rated bottled water in terms of taste, is derived from municipal tap water that undergoes purification, followed by the addition of electrolytes like magnesium sulfate and potassium bicarbonate to enhance its flavor. Therefore, your bottled water may not always be entirely pure and untainted.

Many individuals are worried about contaminants such as lead in their tap water, which can drive them to opt for bottled alternatives. Another significant concern is microplastics—tiny plastic particles present in much of our food and water, originating from various sources including cookware and clothing. According to the nonprofit organization Food & Water Watch, these microplastics can harbor harmful chemicals like phthalates, Bisphenol A (BPA), and flame retardants, which are associated with serious health issues such as cancer, liver damage, reproductive problems, and allergies. While tap water is likely to contain some level of toxic substances and microplastics, one study indicated that tap water samples showed contamination rates ranging from 24% to 100%, whereas bottled water was found to have contaminants in 92% to 100% of cases.

Moreover, tap water does have trace amounts of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), known as "forever chemicals," which are hazardous compounds found in our drinking water, food, and household products. However, a study conducted by Johns Hopkins University revealed that 39 out of 101 bottled water samples tested positive for PFAS.

Which is better, tap or bottled water?

Many individuals opt for bottled water because they believe it tastes better; however, blind taste tests reveal that most people struggle to distinguish between the two. When it comes to avoiding contaminants and saving money, the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a nonprofit organization focused on health and environmental research, advises drinking filtered tap water from a reusable, BPA-free glass or stainless-steel bottle.

Nonetheless, some people still prefer bottled water for its convenience. In certain regions, where plumbing may be outdated and contaminated, or when you're on the move, tap water might not be sufficient or even available. In such situations, it's useful to know that the three brands recognized by EWG for their transparency are Gerber Pure Purified Water, Penta Ultra-Purified Water, and Nestle Pure Life Purified Water, which ranked eighth on Chowhound's list of popular bottled water brands.

In summary, filtered tap water in a reusable bottle is likely the best and most economical choice for accessible clean drinking water, but bottled water from a reputable brand can be a suitable alternative in a pinch.

Is Bottled Water Really Just Repackaged Tap Water?

What's in your water?

Which is better, tap or bottled water?

Recommended

Next up