master-cooks | Is Costco's Wagyu Beef Authentic?

Costco's Wagyu beef has garnered attention for its affordability compared to traditional sources. Wagyu beef, originally from Japan, is renowned for its rich marbling, tenderness, and distinct flavor profile. Authentic Wagyu is typically graded by the Japanese Meat Grading Association, with the highest quality often labeled as A5. However, the term "Wagyu" can be somewhat ambiguous outside Japan, as it encompasses a variety of crossbred cattle. Costco offers both American Wagyu, which is a crossbreed between Japanese Wagyu and American Angus cattle, and sometimes authentic Japanese Wagyu. American Wagyu tends to have less marbling than the purebred Japanese version but still offers a premium experience compared to regular beef. For authenticity, customers should look for specific labeling, such as the Japanese grading or certificates that verify the meat's origin. While Costco's Wagyu may not always match the pure Japanese varieties in terms of marbling and flavor, it is generally considered a high-quality product at a more accessible price point. The availability may vary by location, so it's advisable for consumers to check the product details and labeling to ensure they are getting the type of Wagyu they desire.

Don't overlook American Wagyu

While Japanese Wagyu is often the most coveted, it can be quite pricey, even at retailers like Costco. Thankfully, there are alternatives, such as American Wagyu, which, according to the American Wagyu Association, comes from cattle that are descendants of a few animals imported from Japan in the 1990s. Some farms have successfully raised full-blooded Wagyu cattle in the U.S., while others have developed crossbreeds. Although these crossbred cattle do not meet Japanese standards for authentic Wagyu, they may be preferred by some diners. In an interview with The Food Institute, Nick Fiorentino, owner of The Meatery—a butcher shop certified by the Kobe Beef Association—mentioned that Japanese Wagyu can be too rich for some people, leading him to recommend American or Australian crossbred options instead.

Moreover, Japanese Wagyu steaks are typically sliced much thinner than their American counterparts, as the meat's richness doesn't suit the traditional steak-eating experience. If you attempted to serve it as part of a classic steak and potato meal, you might quickly feel overwhelmed.

While American Wagyu may not possess the same melt-in-your-mouth texture as genuine Japanese beef—primarily due to less marbling—it is more affordable and still offers exceptional quality. If you're eager to try Wagyu without spending a fortune, exploring American Wagyu is definitely a worthwhile option.

Is Costco's Wagyu Beef Authentic?

Don't overlook American Wagyu

Recommended

Next up