master-cooks | Is It A Waste To Use Irish Butter For Cooking Or Baking?

Using Irish butter for cooking or baking is often considered a worthwhile investment rather than a waste, depending on the context and desired outcome. Irish butter, known for its rich, creamy texture and distinct flavor, is made primarily from the milk of grass-fed cows, which contributes to its higher butterfat content and golden color. These qualities can enhance the taste and texture of many dishes, making it a popular choice among chefs and home cooks who seek to elevate their culinary creations. When baking, the superior quality of Irish butter can result in flakier pastries, richer cookies, and more tender cakes, enhancing both flavor and texture. In cooking, it can add depth and a subtle richness to sauces, sautéed vegetables, and other dishes. However, its premium price might make it less appealing for everyday cooking where its unique qualities might not be as noticeable. For recipes where butter is a standout ingredient, such as in butter sauces or simple baked goods like shortbread, the use of Irish butter can be particularly beneficial. Ultimately, whether using Irish butter is considered a waste depends on the specific culinary application and the value one places on the taste and quality it brings to a dish.

Irish butter in the cooking realm

At nearly $10 per pound, Irish butter is nearly twice the cost of typical U.S. brands. This steep price can make many cooks hesitant to use it for sautéing vegetables. However, there are certainly occasions when butter deserves a place in your cooking.

Consider dishes that benefit from a rich, buttery sauce, such as a simple bowl of garlic noodles or a filet of fish that requires a drizzle of beurre blanc. In these cases, Irish butter is far from being a waste. Likewise, many potato dishes, from Duchess potatoes to creamy mashed potatoes, fully embrace the richness of European-style butter, making it an excellent choice.

Beyond spreading Irish butter on your morning toast or chewy bagel, there are plenty of other delightful uses for this luxurious condiment. You can create compound butter for an impressive bread and butter board, slather it on your next Wisconsin-style cheeseburger, or pile it onto a hot baked potato. Rich in vitamins and minerals, many cooks also use Irish butter to craft what they consider the ultimate ghee.

To bake or not to bake

While it's true that butters with a high butterfat content can hinder rising in baking and result in greasier products, this issue can also stem from the absence of cultures in Irish butter. The Institute of Culinary Education (ICE) notes that the ferments found in cultured butter can aid in the rising of your batter or dough. Therefore, even if you're using a butter with a high fat content, the ferments can counteract the dense texture. Generally, Irish butter lacks these ferments, so it's advisable to be cautious when using it in baking recipes that don't specifically call for it, as it may lead to a heavier final product.

That said, Irish butter, despite being uncultured, remains an excellent option for baked goods that emphasize buttery flavors and textures, particularly in recipes where a rich buttery taste or flaky consistency is crucial. Consider dishes like butter cookies, St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake, toffee, an all-butter pie crust, or browned butter chocolate chip cookies. Any baked item that requires lamination, such as croissants or puff pastry, can greatly benefit from this rich European-style butter. Additionally, Irish butter is a fantastic choice for quick breads, where a dense, rich crumb is more desirable than a lofty rise. Recipes like sweet zucchini bread or pound cake are perfect for showcasing the qualities of high-fat Irish butter.

Is It A Waste To Use Irish Butter For Cooking Or Baking?

Irish butter in the cooking realm

To bake or not to bake

Recommended

Next up