master-cooks | Next Time You Make Potato Salad Dress It Like Bobby Flay

Bobby Flay is renowned for his ability to elevate classic dishes with bold flavors and unique twists, and his approach to potato salad is no exception. When making potato salad, Flay suggests starting with high-quality, waxy potatoes like red bliss or Yukon gold, which hold their shape well and provide a creamy texture. He emphasizes the importance of seasoning the potatoes while they’re still warm, allowing them to absorb flavors more effectively. For a vibrant dressing, Flay often incorporates a combination of tangy ingredients such as Dijon mustard, vinegar, and fresh lemon juice, balanced with olive oil for a smooth consistency. Fresh herbs like dill, parsley, or chives add a burst of color and freshness, while additions like capers or pickles can introduce a salty, briny element. Flay isn’t afraid to add unexpected ingredients such as grilled corn or roasted red peppers for extra depth and sweetness. By focusing on layers of flavor and texture, Flay's method transforms a traditional side dish into a standout feature of any meal. His approach encourages creativity and experimentation, allowing you to tailor the salad to your personal taste while maintaining a perfect balance of flavors.

A traditional potato salad dressing

Numerous potato salad recipes from various cultures feature mayonnaise as a primary component. However, Bobby Flay's dressing takes a different approach. By incorporating mustard, vinegar, and olive oil, he places his salad firmly in the vinegar-based dressing category, paying homage to the potato salad's earliest American roots. The Spanish, who brought the potato salad to the New World in the 16th century, used a generous amount of vinegar, spices, and a splash of wine in their starchy creations. German immigrants later added hot potatoes and bacon to the mix, a tradition that Flay honors and enhances with a touch of salt and pepper, along with plenty of chopped green onions.

The use of mayo, or Miracle Whip, as a foundational dressing for potato salad didn't emerge until the 20th century. The same applies to the addition of ingredients like hard-boiled eggs, pickle relish, roasted vegetables, dill, and other regional variations. At some point, potato salads also transitioned from being served warm to being enjoyed cold.

Getting the potatoes right

When Bobby Flay prepares potato salad, even his method of handling the main ingredient reflects his pursuit of the ideal dish. Instead of letting the potatoes cool, he begins chopping and dressing them while they’re still warm. His reasoning? The heat opens up the pores and starches in the potatoes, allowing the dressing's flavors to penetrate deeply. The combination of bacon and its rich, smoky drippings, Dijon mustard, green onions, cider vinegar, olive oil, caramelized red onions, and a dash of parsley harmonizes to provide a burst of flavor from each component in every bite.

The choice of potatoes is crucial in crafting a successful potato salad. Flay avoids using Idaho or russet potatoes, which are typically reserved for baked dishes. Instead, he selects waxy new potatoes, which have a lower starch content than russets. This, along with their high water content, ensures that the vibrant red-skinned potatoes he incorporates into his German potato salad maintain their shape and don’t disintegrate as they mix with the dressing. The result is a beautifully presented potato salad that is as visually appealing as it is delicious.

Next Time You Make Potato Salad Dress It Like Bobby Flay

A traditional potato salad dressing

Getting the potatoes right

Recommended

Next up