The Best Tequila For Margaritas

Using reposada tequila for margaritas

If you're in search of a more refined tequila, Jaime Salas suggests Cuervo Tradicional Reposado as an excellent choice. "It's made from 100% blue agave and aged in charred oak, giving it a distinctly 'tequilero' character. Its flavor profile features cooked agave and stewed tropical fruits, complemented by lingering hints of vanilla, clove, cinnamon, and toffee, making it a fantastic tequila that adds remarkable depth to margaritas," he explains. Reposado, often referred to simply as aged tequila, is tequila that has been matured for 2 to 12 months in whiskey barrels or French oak. This spirit is quite versatile, enjoyable both neat and in cocktails, and it brings a delightful complexity to margaritas.

However, due to its aging, the robust flavor of this tequila may overshadow some of the other ingredients in a margarita, which might not appeal to everyone. Additionally, reposado bottles tend to be pricier than blanco options, which could be a consideration if you're making margaritas on a budget. The same applies to añejo or extra añejo tequilas, which are aged for 1 to 3 years or even longer. Generally, these tequilas are too intense for margaritas and are best enjoyed on their own. Nevertheless, some discerning tequila enthusiasts might appreciate a more robust margarita.

Alternatives to Jose Cuervo for margaritas

Jose Cuervo, while being the most well-known tequila globally, tends to evoke mixed opinions. Some offerings from the brand, particularly those in the Reserva de la Familia line, are superior, but overall, the quality can vary. Despite being the easiest tequila to find in stores and offering competitive prices, there are numerous other brands that utilize 100% blue agave and are budget-friendly.

For just $10 more than Jose Cuervo's Blanco Especial, you can purchase a bottle of the bartender-favored Herradura Blanco tequila for $31.99. This unaged tequila is smooth with subtle vegetal notes and is available at retailers like Total Wine. If your local Trader Joe's carries hard liquor, consider picking up a bottle of Espolon Blanco tequila, priced at a reasonable $24.99, known for its fresh and slightly sweet flavor profile.

If you're interested in reposado tequila, be prepared to spend a bit more for a quality bottle. Herradura is again a recommended choice, with a moderate price of $50. For a more budget-friendly option that doesn't compromise on quality or taste, consider Espanita Reposado ($32) or Tequila Tapatio Reposado ($41). Espanita is surprisingly light and floral for a reposado, while Tapatio offers a hint of sweetness and herbaceous notes.