Tips for reshaping cookies of different types and sizes

While mason jar canning rings can help create uniformity in most standard-sized cookies, they may not be the best choice for shaping your extra-large frozen cookies from Costco. Typically, canning rings are smaller in diameter than these hefty treats, so you'll need to find a round, food-safe item that is slightly larger than the cookies themselves. A large cereal bowl or a clear glass pot lid could work, provided there's enough room to swirl each cookie without it getting stuck.
It's also crucial to consider the height of your cookies. For example, if you've enhanced store-bought cookie dough with tasty add-ins, they are likely to be thick and chewy. The swirling technique won't be effective if your chosen tool compresses them from above; they need room to move. Therefore, an open tool like a biscuit cutter is likely your best option for reshaping cookies loaded with ingredients like white chocolate chips, pretzels, and dried cranberries.
Once your cookies are perfectly shaped, allowing them to cool is essential for maintaining that shape. As mentioned, freshly baked cookies are quite soft (which is why this method works). After swirling each cookie, carefully transfer it to a cooling rack using a spatula. Avoid the temptation to smooth out any imperfections or attempt to swirl them again, as this may lead to broken cookies. However, once they have cooled, they should retain their shape effortlessly.
Recommended

Giada De Laurentiis' Tip For Perfectly Sized Chocolate Chunks

Why Does Fruitcake Have Such A Bad Reputation?

The Secret To Rich, Bakery-Style Cookies Comes In A Box

Cut The Sweetness Of Store-Bought Frosting With An Easy Fix
Next up