master-cooks | The Difference Between An Apple Pie And A Crisp Is All In The Topping

An apple pie and an apple crisp may share the same main ingredient—apples—but they are distinguished by their distinct toppings and overall structure. An apple pie typically features a flaky, buttery crust that envelops the apple filling. The crust can be either a double crust, with both a bottom and top layer of pastry, or a single crust, with just a bottom layer and a lattice or open top. The pie crust is a key component, providing a structured, slightly crispy shell that contrasts with the soft, sweet apple filling. On the other hand, an apple crisp is characterized by its crumbly, streusel-like topping made from a combination of flour, butter, sugar, and often oats or nuts. This topping is sprinkled over the apples, creating a crunchy, textured layer that provides a delightful contrast to the tender, baked apples beneath. Unlike the pie's structured crust, the crisp's topping is more rustic and casual, allowing the apples to take center stage. While both desserts highlight the natural sweetness of apples, the pie's emphasis is on the buttery crust, whereas the crisp focuses on the crunchy topping, offering a more straightforward, homey dessert experience.

Apple pie versus crisp

If you need a quick reminder on the fundamentals of baking, an apple pie consists of a sweet apple filling resting on a rich, buttery crust, all encased in another layer of dough. The top layer can be rolled out into a simple disk or intricately laced and woven into decorative patterns. The filling is created from sliced, cooked apples enveloped in a thick syrup, often enhanced with a hint of cinnamon. This syrupy mixture is surrounded by dough on all sides. For a delicious and crunchy pie crust, you might substitute sour cream for water or use butter instead of shortening. This crust is what sets a pie apart from a crisp.

A crisp, on the other hand, may have a similar filling to that of a pie. An apple crisp typically features sweet, cooked apples but lacks a traditional crust. Instead, it is baked in a large, oven-safe dish and topped with a generous layer of crumble, usually made from a blend of butter, flour, and sugar.

It's all in the topping

The distinction between an apple pie and an apple crisp can be a bit perplexing due to the presence of a crumble topping. A crumble is essential for a crisp; however, certain varieties of apple pie can also feature generous amounts of buttery, sugary crumble on top. Dutch apple pies, or crumble-topped apple pies, still showcase apples encased in a crust, but they are finished with a substantial layer of crumble instead of a traditional pie crust on top.

In contrast, a crisp topping is quite similar but typically includes oats in the crumble mixture. These nutty, crunchy oats may even be the inspiration behind the dish's name. As the dessert bakes, the oats become toasted, contributing to the crisp texture of the topping. Additionally, an apple crisp does not have a crusty edge around the sides; it is simply contained by the dish it is baked in. When served alongside a delicious scoop of vanilla ice cream, a crisp tends to lose some of its form, transforming into a warm, gooey blend of layered apples, cinnamon, and sugar.

The Difference Between An Apple Pie And A Crisp Is All In The Topping

Apple pie versus crisp

It's all in the topping

Recommended

Next up