The Easy Way To Incorporate Unexpected Flavors Into Your Sugar Cookies

Incorporating unexpected flavors into sugar cookies can transform this classic treat into a delightful surprise. Start by experimenting with various extracts. While vanilla is traditional, try adding almond, coconut, or even lavender extract to your dough for a subtle yet intriguing twist. Spices are another great way to add depth to your cookies. A pinch of cinnamon, cardamom, or nutmeg can elevate the flavor profile, making each bite more complex. Consider zesting citrus fruits like lemon, lime, or orange into your dough for a refreshing burst of flavor that complements the sweetness. For a more adventurous approach, incorporate finely chopped herbs such as rosemary or basil, which can add an unexpected but pleasant earthiness. Don't shy away from savory elements; a sprinkle of sea salt or crushed black pepper can contrast beautifully with the sugar, creating a sophisticated balance. Similarly, infusing your dough with finely ground nuts like pistachios or pecans can add both texture and a nutty richness. Finally, experiment with different types of sugar, such as brown sugar or coconut sugar, to introduce hints of caramel or tropical notes. With these simple adjustments, you can transform ordinary sugar cookies into a flavorful culinary experience.
Advertisement

Making your cookies stand out

The most appealing aspect of focusing on the glaze is its simplicity — usually, you just combine powdered sugar with a liquid of your choice or an extract mixed into a little milk, and your glaze is ready to go. If you prefer a dairy-free option, you can substitute water or a non-dairy milk suitable for baking. For a thicker consistency, opt for heavy whipping cream. When it comes to decoration, feel free to use food coloring, sprinkles (also known as jimmies), marzipan, or crushed candy canes — let your creativity shine and coordinate the decorations with the flavor of your glaze for a harmonious dessert.

If you’re more inclined to enjoy cookies than bake them, or if you simply can’t wait for your cookie dough to chill, Christina Tosi has exciting news: This year, Milk Bar is partnering with McCormick to offer a limited-time Candy Cane Pretzel Bark Cookie, which will be available for free at select locations in NYC, LA, and DC on December 4, also known as National Cookie Day, as part of the McCormick Cookie Quest. These cookies will also be available for purchase at the same locations until December 31.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement