master-cooks | What Is Cannoli Filling Actually?

Cannoli filling is a creamy, smooth mixture traditionally made from ricotta cheese, a staple in Italian cuisine. The ricotta is often blended until it achieves a silky texture, sometimes strained to remove excess moisture, ensuring the filling is rich and not watery. To enhance its flavor, sugar is added, typically confectioners' sugar for its fine texture, which dissolves easily and maintains the filling's creaminess. Vanilla extract or a hint of citrus zest, such as orange or lemon, is often incorporated to add depth and aroma to the filling. Depending on regional variations and personal preferences, additional ingredients like cinnamon or nutmeg might be sprinkled in for warmth and spice. For a touch of luxury, some recipes include small pieces of chocolate or candied fruits, adding texture and bursts of sweetness. The filling is spooned or piped into crisp, fried pastry shells, creating a delightful contrast between the crunchy exterior and the luscious center. While the traditional filling focuses on simplicity and freshness, modern variations may incorporate mascarpone cheese for added richness or whipped cream for an airy, lighter texture, allowing each cannoli to offer a unique taste experience.

Not all cannoli are created equal

Interestingly, the filling for American cannoli differs from that used in Italy. Italians traditionally prepare theirs with sheep's milk ricotta, while Americans tend to favor cow's milk ricotta. Sheep's milk is recognized for its stronger, tangier flavor, which contributes to a more robust texture in the cheese — both of which create a distinctly different cannoli experience.

Americans opt for cow's milk ricotta in their cannoli due to its greater availability and milder taste. However, this type of cheese has a much looser consistency compared to sheep's milk ricotta, which is where the previously mentioned icing sugar comes into play. This sugar — or sometimes another thickening agent — is added to the ricotta, resulting in a sweeter flavor for American cannoli compared to their Italian counterparts.

Additionally, Italians prefer their cannoli fillings to be straightforward, avoiding excessive garnishes. The Italian version typically comes in two sizes: a smaller 3.5-inch variety known as cannolicchio and a larger traditional version. Cannoli are also filled to order rather than being pre-filled, ensuring the pastry maintains its crispness.

How to customize your cannoli filling

In addition to recreating the classic Italian filling with sheep's milk ricotta, if you can find it, there are numerous ways to personalize the flavor of your cannoli filling when preparing this dessert at home. Thanks to its creamy and relatively mild taste, ricotta cheese is quite adaptable when it comes to incorporating additional ingredients.

If you enjoy chocolate, think about blending in a hazelnut spread like Nutella (another delightful Italian creation), some melted chocolate, or even a bit of sifted cocoa powder if you're short on time. To enhance the presentation, garnish the cannoli with finely chopped roasted hazelnuts and a whole Ferrero Rocher chocolate (also Italian), secured with melted chocolate.

Another delightful option is to infuse the filling with lemon — adding some finely grated lemon zest and a squeeze of lemon juice, or a spoonful of lemon curd swirled into the mixture will provide a delicious, citrusy flavor that’s distinctly Mediterranean. Using limes or oranges can yield a similar effect, and these flavors can be complemented with the same candied fruit as a garnish. Speaking of fruit, incorporating jam, berry coulis, or freeze-dried fruit powder can also enhance both the filling and the topping. No matter which direction you choose, your cannoli — particularly its filling — is sure to be 'bellissimo.'

What Is Cannoli Filling Actually?

Not all cannoli are created equal

How to customize your cannoli filling

Recommended

Next up