Why It's Illegal For Delaware Restaurants To Serve Margarine

Delaware's unusual regulation prohibiting the serving of margarine in restaurants is deeply rooted in historical and cultural contexts. This law dates back to the early 20th century when margarine, a butter substitute, faced significant opposition from the dairy industry. At the time, dairy farmers and producers were concerned about the rising popularity of margarine, which posed a threat to their livelihoods. To protect the dairy industry, laws were enacted in several states, including Delaware, to restrict or ban the use of margarine in various settings. These laws were supported by powerful dairy lobbies and were often justified by arguments related to health, quality, and tradition. Over the years, while many other states have repealed similar laws, Delaware's prohibition remains on the books, albeit rarely enforced. It serves as a reminder of the historical tensions between agricultural industries and the evolving food market. In practice, this regulation has little impact on the day-to-day operations of modern Delaware restaurants, as consumer preferences and industry standards have shifted considerably since the law's inception. Nonetheless, it highlights the complex interplay between legislation, industry interests, and consumer choice in the food sector's history.
Advertisement

The history behind the margarine ban

Despite the widespread disdain for margarine, its creation was driven by necessity. Originally developed in the 1860s in France as an affordable substitute for butter during a time of scarcity, the first margarine was a mixture of beef tallow and churned milk. Today, modern margarine is classified by the state of Delaware as a combination of various fats and oils designed to mimic the appearance and texture of genuine yellow butter.

This budget-friendly alternative made its way to the United States in 1871. Its lower cost posed a threat to butter sales and the livelihoods of dairy farmers. In response, the dairy industry and various states acted swiftly: by 1877, seven states had enacted a complete ban on margarine, while regulations were established in 17 others. Wisconsin was the last state to lift its total ban on margarine in 1967. Although margarine can now be legally purchased in every state, a few states still enforce regulations similar to those in Delaware.

When margarine first entered the U.S. market, it was regarded as a lesser product compared to butter. Many consumers today may still share this view, and they deserve to know whether they are consuming the genuine article (at least in certain states).

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement