master-cooks | Why Using The Toothpick Test Is A Mistake For Your Brownies

The toothpick test, a common method for checking the doneness of baked goods, often leads to misleading results when it comes to brownies. Brownies are known for their rich, fudgy texture, and using a toothpick to test them can cause overbaking. When a toothpick inserted into brownies comes out clean, it usually means that the brownies have baked past their ideal point of doneness, resulting in a drier, cake-like consistency rather than their signature gooey center. The residual heat of the pan continues to cook brownies after they are removed from the oven, so pulling them out when the toothpick emerges clean exacerbates this issue. Instead of relying on the toothpick test, bakers should look for visual cues and a gentle touch to determine when brownies are ready. The edges should be set and start to pull away from the sides of the pan, while the center should appear slightly underbaked but not liquid. Allowing brownies to cool in the pan will help them firm up without losing their desired texture. By avoiding the toothpick test, bakers can achieve perfectly dense and moist brownies every time.

How to adjust your toothpick test for brownies

The toothpick test is effective, but understanding its results is key when it comes to brownies. This knowledge is essential for both fudgy and cake-like varieties. If you insert a clean toothpick and it comes out completely clean, you’ve missed the mark. You want the toothpick to show some moisture without being drenched in batter; a little stickiness indicates that there’s still enough moisture for the brownies to continue cooking for a few minutes after being removed from the oven.

To get it right, start testing a few minutes earlier than the recipe suggests (and always use a fresh, clean toothpick). You’re aiming for that perfect moment in the center of the pan when the toothpick comes out with just a few gooey crumbs for fudgy brownies, or a few crumbs for cake-like brownies.

If the toothpick test isn’t providing clear guidance, keep in mind other important tips to prevent over-baking. For instance, take the brownies out as soon as you see cracks forming on the surface, and gently jiggle the pan to check if the center is set. If your brownies are baking unevenly, leading to tough edges and a gooey center, try placing them on the center rack instead of the bottom, or consider using a water bath, similar to how you would for custards.

Why Using The Toothpick Test Is A Mistake For Your Brownies

How to adjust your toothpick test for brownies

Recommended

Next up