How Massachusetts Put Its Own Sweet Spin On The Classic Peanut Butter Sandwich

Massachusetts has added its own unique twist to the classic peanut butter sandwich, creating a beloved regional favorite known as the Fluffernutter. This delightful variation replaces the traditional jelly or jam with Marshmallow Fluff, a sweet, spreadable marshmallow cream that was invented in Somerville, Massachusetts, in the early 20th century. The combination of creamy peanut butter and fluffy marshmallow spread results in a sweet and savory treat that has become a staple in lunchboxes across the state. The Fluffernutter's origins can be traced back to World War I, when the original marshmallow creme was first introduced, and its popularity soared in the 1960s as it became a nostalgic comfort food. The sandwich's simplicity, requiring only a few ingredients and minimal preparation, has contributed to its enduring appeal. Despite its sugary nature, the Fluffernutter holds a special place in the hearts of many Massachusetts residents, often evoking cherished childhood memories. Efforts to recognize the Fluffernutter as the official state sandwich have been made, highlighting its cultural significance. Today, the Fluffernutter remains a symbol of Massachusetts' culinary ingenuity, offering a sweet spin on a classic favorite that continues to delight both young and old alike.
Advertisement

Reviving the fluffernutter — from wartime necessity to Bay State staple

As convenience foods gained popularity in the 1960s, the creators of Marshmallow Fluff recognized an opportunity to turn their product into a household favorite. They revamped Emma Curtis's original Liberty Sandwich recipe by replacing the dense whole-grain bread with soft white bread. The updated recipe quickly became a hit and has remained a beloved choice in Massachusetts, even appearing on lunch menus in public schools.

Over time, the recipe made its way to the peanut-loving South, where it also became a beloved classic. Given that peanuts and peanut butter are staples of Southern cuisine, it’s no surprise that locals embraced fluffernutters. They even created various twists on this sweet treat, such as drizzling chocolate spread on top or using marshmallow fluff to elevate a standard PB&J.

Today, marshmallow fluff not only fills this nostalgic sandwich but is also a key ingredient in Rice Krispie treats, easy fudge recipes, and holiday sweet potato casserole. Remarkably, marshmallow fluff has even been sent to space, allowing astronauts aboard the International Space Station (ISS) to enjoy fluffernutters while observing the universe.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement