master-cooks | Is Cream Soda Just Vanilla Flavored Root Beer?

Cream soda and root beer are both classic soft drinks with distinct flavors, though they share some similarities. Cream soda is primarily known for its sweet, vanilla-forward taste. Its flavor profile is often described as smooth and creamy, reminiscent of vanilla ice cream, which is why it pairs well with various desserts. The drink's base can include a variety of ingredients, such as vanilla bean, vanilla extract, or even synthetic vanilla flavoring, giving it that signature taste. Root beer, on the other hand, is a more complex beverage traditionally made from the roots of the sassafras tree or sarsaparilla vine. It boasts a rich, earthy flavor with hints of spices like anise, nutmeg, or wintergreen, creating a unique and aromatic experience. Although some root beers may contain mild vanilla notes, these are typically not the dominant flavors. While both beverages have a sweet and sometimes creamy taste, cream soda and root beer are distinct entities. Root beer's spiced and herbal characteristics set it apart from the straightforward vanilla sweetness of cream soda. Thus, cream soda is not simply a vanilla-flavored root beer, but rather a separate and unique drink with its own flavor profile.

The many recipes of cream soda

While many contemporary sodas can be traced back to 19th century America, the history of cream soda appears to diverge from that of root beer. The earliest mention of cream soda can be found in the 1852 edition of a magazine called Michigan Farmer, which featured a recipe with entirely different ingredients, including an egg for a frothy consistency (ironically, NYC's egg cream soda does not contain any egg). This recipe described it as a summer beverage that aligned with the "Maine Law," enacted the previous year, which was among the first laws in the U.S. to prohibit alcohol.

Interestingly, what Americans today recognize as modern, golden-hued cream soda may have several different origins. In Brooklyn, New York, the company now known as Dr. Brown's began marketing a tan, vanilla-flavored soda in 1869, and it still labels its cans as "the original cream soda." Other theories propose that the term originated from soda fountain workers during the Great Depression, who referred to any soda that could be mixed with milk or vanilla ice cream as "cream soda." Given the popularity of root beer floats, one could argue that root beer might fit the definition of cream soda in this context, but not necessarily vice versa.

It's also important to note that cream soda has different meanings in various parts of the world. In Canada, Crush-brand cream soda is a vibrant pink and quite sweet, while in South Africa, Sparletta-brand creme soda is green and has a flavor profile more reminiscent of raspberries than vanilla.

Is Cream Soda Just Vanilla-Flavored Root Beer?

The many recipes of cream soda

Recommended

Next up