Is There Enough Caffeine In Coffee Ice Cream To Make You Jittery?

Coffee ice cream, a delightful treat for many, often raises questions about its caffeine content and whether it can cause jitteriness. The caffeine level in coffee ice cream varies depending on the brand and recipe but generally is much lower than a typical cup of coffee. A standard serving might contain anywhere from 10 to 45 milligrams of caffeine, whereas an average cup of brewed coffee can contain around 95 milligrams or more. For most people, the caffeine in coffee ice cream is not sufficient to cause noticeable jitteriness, especially compared to the caffeine intake from regular coffee. However, sensitivity to caffeine can vary among individuals. For those who are particularly sensitive, even the small amount in coffee ice cream might be enough to cause slight nervousness or restlessness. Additionally, consuming large quantities of coffee ice cream might increase the caffeine intake, potentially leading to mild jitteriness. It's also important to consider other ingredients, such as sugar, which can sometimes mimic or amplify the effects of caffeine. Overall, while coffee ice cream does contain caffeine, for most people, it is unlikely to cause jitters unless consumed in large amounts or by those with a high sensitivity to caffeine.
Advertisement

Comparing coffee ice creams

Häagen-Dazs serves as a solid starting point since it contains a relatively average amount of caffeine for coffee ice cream. In contrast, other popular supermarket brands have considerably lower caffeine levels, with Breyer's offering 20 mg per two-thirds cup serving and Edy's/Dreyer's (which varies by region) containing just 15 mg per serving. On the flip side, Ben & Jerry's coffee flavors pack much more caffeine, averaging around 47-49 mg per serving. This includes options like "Coffee, Coffee, BuzzBuzzBuzz," featuring espresso bean fudge chunks, "Brewed to Matter," which has fudge chunks and brownie batter, and "Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch," loaded with toffee pieces.

Determining the minimum caffeine amount needed to feel a noticeable effect is challenging, as it differs from person to person; some may metabolize caffeine more rapidly or intensely than others. Unless you know you're particularly sensitive to caffeine, indulging in a midnight snack of coffee ice cream shouldn't disrupt your sleep. Plus, if you finish an entire Häagen-Dazs carton, you'll likely notice the 24 grams of sugar more than the caffeine content.

No buzz in coffee ice cream

If you're curious about the caffeine content in coffee ice cream, making it at home is a straightforward option. Ice cream primarily consists of milk, heavy cream, and sugar, and for coffee ice cream, you simply incorporate coffee grounds, brewed coffee, or even espresso. In a typical homemade recipe, a pint usually contains around half a cup of coffee, which accounts for about a quarter of the final product. By making it yourself, you have the option to use decaffeinated coffee to avoid any caffeine concerns, and you can easily monitor the amount of coffee or espresso you add to ensure it gives you the desired boost. Additionally, if you own an ice cream maker, you can efficiently prepare a large batch of iced coffee as well.

Overall, the caffeine in ice cream is more akin to that found in Coca-Cola than in regular coffee. A can of Coke contains 34 mg of caffeine, while a can of Diet Coke has 46 mg. If you can enjoy a late-night soda, you should have no issues indulging in some coffee ice cream at night.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement