master-cooks | Remember When Pepsi Challenged Coke Into An Identity Crisis?

In the early 1980s, the cola wars between Pepsi and Coca-Cola reached a peak with the famous Pepsi Challenge. This marketing campaign involved blind taste tests where consumers were asked to choose between Pepsi and Coke. Surprisingly, many participants preferred the taste of Pepsi, a revelation that shook Coca-Cola's confidence. The results of the Pepsi Challenge suggested a shift in consumer preferences, prompting Coca-Cola to rethink its strategy. In response, Coca-Cola made a bold move by introducing "New Coke," a reformulated version of its classic drink, in 1985. The intention was to offer a sweeter taste that could compete with Pepsi's growing popularity. However, this decision backfired, as loyal Coke drinkers were outraged by the change. The backlash was so intense that Coca-Cola eventually reintroduced the original formula as "Coca-Cola Classic," acknowledging the enduring appeal of its traditional flavor. The episode highlighted the complexity of brand identity and consumer loyalty. While the Pepsi Challenge initially seemed a victory for Pepsi, it ultimately reinforced the deep emotional connection many had with Coca-Cola's original product. This period remains a fascinating example of how competitive pressure can prompt iconic brands to reassess and reaffirm their core identities.

New Coke, Coke Classic, and regular old Pepsi

Although the new Coke surprisingly outperformed both Coke Classic and Pepsi in a taste test, the revamped formula quickly ignited widespread backlash. Coca-Cola received over 400,000 letters urging the company to revert to the original flavor. To address the discontented customers, the classic formula was reintroduced under the name "Coke Classic," while the less favored version continued to be marketed as "New Coke." Launched on April 23, 1985, it took less than three months for company executives to announce the return of the cherished original Coke formula during a press conference on July 11.

Winning back the loyalty of its drinkers proved to be relatively straightforward. Although Pepsi managed to surpass Coca-Cola that year, Coke Classic remained the preferred choice among fans, and by 1986, the soft drink regained its lead over its rival. Today, Coca-Cola continues to be the most popular soda in the United States, with some establishments that previously offered Pepsi products now switching to Coke. Diet Coke has also emerged as a strong competitor, gaining immense popularity and being recognized by Chowhound as one of the best diet sodas available. Unfortunately, New Coke is one of the discontinued beverages that will not return, having been removed from shelves in 2002, although it made a brief comeback in 2019 when Coca-Cola collaborated with "Stranger Things" to promote the show's third season. For those who missed the opportunity in 2019 and still wish to experience New Coke, many skeptics on Reddit suggest that curious consumers "just drink a Pepsi."

Remember When Pepsi Challenged Coke Into An Identity Crisis?

New Coke, Coke Classic, and regular old Pepsi

Recommended

Next up