master-cooks | Room Temperature Vs. Cold Butter: Which Is Better For Biscuits?

When it comes to making biscuits, the temperature of the butter can significantly affect the texture and flavor of the final product. Room temperature butter is soft and pliable, making it easier to blend evenly with flour and other ingredients. This can result in a more uniform dough and a tender biscuit with a fine crumb. The soft texture allows for better incorporation of air, which can lead to a lighter, fluffier biscuit. On the other hand, cold butter, straight from the refrigerator, creates small, solid pieces within the dough. As the biscuits bake, the cold butter melts and creates steam, leading to flakier layers. This method is often preferred for those seeking a more traditional, flaky biscuit texture. The choice between room temperature and cold butter ultimately depends on personal preference and the desired outcome. If a tender, cake-like biscuit is preferred, room temperature butter may be the better choice. For those who favor a structured, flaky texture, cold butter is likely the way to go. Each method has its merits, and experimenting with both can help bakers discover which technique best suits their taste and texture preferences.

Keeping it cold

When you're getting ready to make biscuits, ensure your butter is as cold as possible. Avoid taking it out of the fridge until you're ready to mix it with your flour. Cut the butter into small pieces and use your hands or a pastry blender to combine it with the flour, being careful not to overwork the dough. Keep in mind that this method allows for the butter to melt into the dough, which negates the advantages of using cold butter.

To maintain the coldness of your butter, consider placing a stick (or two) in the freezer overnight. This will help keep it cool enough to prevent melting into your dough. However, frozen butter can be challenging to cut into smaller pieces. Instead of cutting, use a box grater to shred it into fine pieces. This technique promotes a more uniform dough, resulting in flaky, soft, and buttery biscuits. If your butter has softened during the mixing process, you can always refrigerate your uncooked biscuits before baking. This will help firm up the butter and relax the gluten in the dough, leading to a more tender final product.

The science of biscuits

Incorporating cold butter into baking is a well-established technique. Many baked items, including croissants and pie crusts, also rely on cold butter for the lamination process. This involves folding butter into the dough multiple times to create layers that transform into a flaky, buttery pastry when baked. While most biscuits aren't laminated, the way butter is loosely mixed into the dough creates similar effects. These clusters of butter in biscuit or croissant dough generate steam in the oven due to the water content in the butter. As the water vaporizes, it creates air pockets that develop into the layers or "flakes" in your baked goods. If the butter is not cold, it will blend into the flour, preventing air pockets from forming, resulting in a denser, flatter, and tougher biscuit.

However, using cold butter is not the sole secret to achieving a soft biscuit. Buttermilk, a common ingredient in biscuit recipes, is also an excellent choice for softening the dough. Like cold butter, buttermilk serves as a mild leavening agent due to its fat and acid content. Additionally, it imparts a delightful tangy flavor to your biscuits that may be absent if you only use cream. Combining buttermilk with frozen butter can elevate your baked treats while ensuring a tender center.

Room Temperature Vs. Cold Butter: Which Is Better For Biscuits?

Keeping it cold

The science of biscuits

Recommended

Next up