Semifreddo Vs Ice Cream: What's The Difference?

Semifreddo and ice cream are both creamy, frozen desserts, but they differ in texture, ingredients, and preparation methods. Semifreddo, an Italian dessert, translates to "half cold" and has a lighter, mousse-like consistency. It's made by folding whipped cream into a mixture of sugar, eggs, and flavorings, such as chocolate or fruit, and doesn't require an ice cream maker. Instead, it is poured into a mold and frozen, resulting in a soft, airy texture that's easy to slice. Ice cream, on the other hand, is churned, creating a denser and creamier texture. It typically consists of a base made from milk, cream, sugar, and sometimes eggs, which is then churned in an ice cream maker. This process incorporates air and prevents the formation of large ice crystals, leading to a smooth and rich consistency. The primary difference lies in the preparation and texture. Semifreddo is less dense and can be made without special equipment, making it more accessible for home cooks. In contrast, ice cream's churning process creates a thicker and creamier treat. Both desserts offer unique sensory experiences, with semifreddo being ideal for those seeking a lighter option, while ice cream provides a classic, indulgent treat.
Advertisement

How to prepare semifreddo and ice cream

Typically, semifreddo is prepared by making a base of sugar and egg yolks, which is combined and gently heated in a double boiler. This mixture is then whipped until it becomes frothy, light in color, nearly quadruples in volume, and drizzles off the whisk in ribbons. Next, the egg mixture is folded into a simple yet reliable whipped cream that has been beaten to medium peaks. The resulting batter is poured into a loaf pan that has been pre-chilled in the freezer and lined with plastic wrap, then frozen for a minimum of eight hours or overnight.

French-style ice cream, on the other hand, closely resembles the preparation of semifreddo. The egg yolk and sugar mixture is whipped (without heating) until it reaches the ribbon stage, while the milk, cream, and salt are heated until simmering. The egg yolk mixture is then tempered before being combined with the hot cream, and the mixture is gently heated until it coats the back of a spoon and a line remains when a finger is drawn through it. After the mixture cools completely and "ages" overnight in the refrigerator, it is churned in an ice cream maker for about 20 minutes.

Presentation and texture

If you've ever enjoyed semifreddo at your favorite Italian eatery, you know it's presented in slices. This sophisticated dessert is entirely shaped in a loaf pan, cut into one-inch pieces, and garnished with fruit coulis or chocolate sauce—usually reflecting the additional flavors blended into the original recipe. Much like ice cream, semifreddo is highly adaptable and can be infused with a variety of flavors, from limoncello and raspberry to coffee, pistachio, or passionfruit. Although it lacks thickening agents, semifreddo is often likened to a frozen mousse. It has a creamy, airy texture, melts rapidly, and dissolves almost immediately on your palate.

Our cherished ice cream, whether made with a custard base or not, is most commonly served in scoops. Just think of those animated characters attempting to enjoy towering cones before they melt in the sweltering summer heat or topple over. While semifreddo can occasionally be served in scoops, this presentation is generally reserved for ice cream-filled waffle cones or placed atop a split banana. In contrast to semifreddo, a spoonful of French-style ice cream is dense and somewhat chewy, lingering on your lips and melting more gradually in your mouth.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement