master-cooks | Shortening Is The Secret To Super Fluffy Homemade Frosting

Shortening is often overlooked in the quest for the perfect homemade frosting, yet it plays a crucial role in achieving a super fluffy texture. Unlike butter, which can melt quickly and lead to a denser consistency, shortening remains stable at room temperature, providing a consistently light and airy result. This stability is particularly beneficial when decorating cakes or cupcakes, as the frosting holds its shape for longer periods, making it ideal for intricate designs or hot climates. Another advantage of using shortening is its neutral flavor, allowing the other ingredients in the frosting, such as vanilla or almond extracts, to shine through without being overshadowed. It also contributes to a whiter base, which is perfect for those aiming for a pure white frosting or those planning to add food coloring. By incorporating shortening, bakers can create a frosting that is not only fluffy but also versatile. For the best results, it is recommended to use a combination of shortening and butter. This approach marries the flavor richness of butter with the structural benefits of shortening. The result is a frosting that is both delicious and aesthetically pleasing, making it a must-try secret ingredient for any baking enthusiast looking to elevate their homemade confections.

Why shortening is so effective in frosting

However, the advantages of shortening extend beyond its ability to create fluffier frosting. One significant benefit is its shelf stability, allowing cakes frosted with shortening to remain at room temperature for several days. Other frostings, like buttercreams—specifically those without eggs, cream cheese, or whipped cream—can also endure a few days at room temperature. In contrast, butter-based buttercreams may start to melt if not refrigerated. Shortening-based frostings, on the other hand, can be kept at room temperature for up to two days without the same melting risk as their butter counterparts. Furthermore, many shortenings, such as Crisco, are vegan, making them an excellent choice for individuals with specific dietary needs.

You also won’t have to worry about your shortening-based icing wilting. This is due to shortening's higher melting point compared to butter, which allows shortening-based icings to withstand warmer temperatures. Its elevated melting point means you can frost a slightly warm cake without fear of melting or losing shape. Additionally, the pure, white color of shortening can create a bright white icing for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies, especially when combined with confectioners' sugar and clear vanilla extract.

Shortening and butter can work together in your frosting

For those accustomed to creating butter-based frostings, transitioning to shortening may feel daunting. However, it doesn't have to be an all-or-nothing decision. While pure shortening frostings are a viable option for home bakers and are commonly found in commercial bakeries, you can adopt a more balanced approach to incorporating shortening into your recipes.

There's no need to choose exclusively between butter and shortening when you can use both. To achieve the ideal blend of butter and shortening in your frosting, simply use equal parts of each. This combination will provide your frosting with the wonderful texture of shortening while retaining the rich and unique flavor of butter. Additionally, this method will offer some of the advantages of shortening-based frostings, such as improved heat resistance. So, the next time you're preparing a scrumptious cake, consider reaching for your tub of shortening instead of butter for your frosting needs.

Shortening Is The Secret To Super Fluffy Homemade Frosting

Why shortening is so effective in frosting

Shortening and butter can work together in your frosting

Recommended

Next up