The Hands-Down Best Cheese For Nachos

When it comes to crafting the perfect plate of nachos, the choice of cheese can make all the difference. The best cheese for nachos should melt smoothly, complement the other ingredients, and provide a rich, creamy flavor. Cheddar cheese is often considered the go-to choice due to its sharpness and excellent melting properties. It adds a classic tangy taste that pairs well with jalapeños, salsa, and other toppings. Monterey Jack is another popular option, known for its mild flavor and ability to melt into a velvety texture, making it ideal for achieving that gooey, irresistible layer. For those who enjoy a bit of spice, Pepper Jack offers a delightful kick with its blend of hot peppers, adding an extra dimension to the nacho experience. Colby cheese, with its mild and creamy profile, is also a worthy contender, often used in combination with cheddar for a balanced flavor. Blending different cheeses can enhance the complexity and depth of flavors, creating a more dynamic dish. Ultimately, the best cheese for nachos is one that aligns with personal taste preferences while ensuring a smooth, indulgent melt that elevates this beloved snack.
Advertisement

What makes cheddar and Jack so special?

The origins of cheddar in Cheddar Village, Somerset, England, aren't what make it an excellent choice for nachos; rather, it's the unique process of its production. Cheddar is crafted from layers of sliced cheese curds, and its flavor varies with aging. Mild cheddar, the youngest variety, ages for one to three months, while vintage cheddar, the oldest, matures for 12 to 24 months, often resulting in the sharpest flavor profile.

This vibrant orange cheese is produced from cow's milk. If you're aiming for creamy and buttery notes in your game-day nachos, mild cheddar is the perfect option. Conversely, for a sharper, more intense flavor, opt for sharp or even vintage cheddar if available.

Jack cheese, also referred to as Monterrey Jack, is another cow's milk cheese. On its own, Jack is mild and creamy, making it a versatile choice. When combined with other cheeses like cheddar or colby, it develops a distinct flavor. For those who enjoy spicy nachos, pepper Jack, infused with fresh herbs, garlic, sweet peppers, and jalapeños, provides a creamy and zesty twist, making it an excellent addition to your nacho recipes.

What to know about chihuahua and cotija cheeses

Chihuahua cheese made its way to Northern Mexico through the Mennonites in the 1920s. This mild cheese features subtle notes of butter and a slight tang in its flavor. It is produced from cow's milk using a method similar to that of cheddar cheese. The process involves forming the milk into curds, from which the whey is drained. These warm curds then blend together before being placed in cheesecloth to harden into cheese wheels. Due to its excellent melting properties, Chihuahua cheese is a perfect choice for your nacho recipes.

Cotija cheese, originating from Michoacán, Mexico, has a crumbly texture reminiscent of feta. This cow's milk cheese requires a couple of months to age and shares a similar tanginess and saltiness with feta. If you can't find cotija, substituting feta in your nacho recipe will work well. Cotija is a white cheese that has a feta-like consistency when young and takes on a texture closer to parmesan as it ages.

When considering melting cheeses, cotija is less likely to melt completely. It retains a slightly crumbly texture, but what it lacks in meltiness, it compensates for with its robust flavor, enhancing your nachos. If you prefer fully melted cheese on your nachos, feel free to use cheeses that melt effortlessly. Just remember to sprinkle some cotija on top for an incredible flavor that even dedicated nacho enthusiasts like Dan Whalen are sure to appreciate.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement