What Is The Worst Frozen Pizza At Costco? Sadly, Their Own

Costco is renowned for its bulk products and competitive prices, but not all offerings meet the mark. Surprisingly, one of the most underwhelming products in their lineup is their own Kirkland Signature frozen pizza. While the brand typically delivers quality across various categories, its frozen pizza falls short in several areas. The crust often emerges as a major disappointment; it tends to be too thick and doughy, lacking the desired crispiness and flavor that pizza enthusiasts crave. The sauce is another letdown, as it can be bland and overly sweet, failing to provide the rich, tangy taste that complements a good pizza. Additionally, the cheese and toppings can be sparse, leaving some bites with an unsatisfying amount of flavor. The overall texture and taste do not compare well to other brands available at Costco, which offer a more authentic and enjoyable pizza experience. Despite the convenience and affordability of Kirkland Signature frozen pizza, its quality leaves much to be desired. Many customers find themselves opting for other brands within Costco's selection, seeking a better balance of taste, texture, and toppings. While Costco excels in many areas, their frozen pizza serves as a reminder that not every product can be a winner.
Advertisement

Why Costco's frozen pepperoni pizza doesn't stand out

Like many other products, the standards for frozen pizza at Costco are quite high. This is partly why Kirkland Signature pepperoni pizza tends to be more of a disappointment than a delight. Each variety was assessed for flavor and texture, focusing on the three key elements: sauce, toppings, and crust. While appearance and value were also taken into account, they were not as crucial to the overall dining experience.

With an abundance of cheese and pepperoni, Costco's store brand frozen pepperoni pizza certainly looks appetizing when it comes out of the oven, but its flavor is rather average. There’s nothing particularly remarkable about its taste or texture. The crust is crispy but lacks distinct flavor, and the sauce and toppings are unremarkable in terms of seasoning.

Mills suggests it as an economical choice that kids will likely enjoy, though it may leave adults craving something more exciting. Given the variety of other frozen pizzas available at Costco—many featuring multiple cheese types, richer sauces, or exceptionally high-quality crusts—there are definitely better alternatives. Pepperoni pizza enthusiasts will be pleased to know that the topping shines in a different product that ranks higher on the list. While Costco's version of the classic pie may not compel you to go for a second slice, it’s clear that the classic can be executed in a truly delicious manner.

Not all of Costco's frozen pizzas fall flat in flavor

While Kirkland's frozen pepperoni pizza may not be the best choice, Costco offers a few other store brand alternatives that are worth considering. If you enjoy classic cheese pizza, their version ranks in the middle tier. Not only is it $2 less expensive than the meat-topped option, but it also has a better taste. Mills points out that the sauce and cheese are enhanced with herbs and salt, which elevate their flavors. The main drawback? The cheese's appearance after baking could be improved.

Another standout option is the Kirkland supreme cauliflower crust frozen pizza, which nearly tops the list. Although it is pricier per pie, it boasts delicious toppings like roasted zucchini and sausage that justify the extra cost. If you're hesitant about the gluten-free crust, Mills assures that it comes out delightfully thin and crispy—a feature that some other cauliflower crusts on the list fail to deliver.

Of course, if you're eager to enjoy dinner right after arriving home, you can always visit Costco's food court after picking up a frozen pizza or two for later. As one of the largest pizza chains in the country, their hot and fresh pepperoni pizza definitely surpasses the less satisfying frozen version in both taste and size.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement