master-cooks | What's The Best Beer For Steak And Ale Pies?

When it comes to pairing beer with steak and ale pies, the goal is to complement the rich and hearty flavors of the dish. A robust and flavorful beer enhances the savory notes of the steak while balancing the pie's overall richness. Traditional English ales, such as a classic English bitter or a malty brown ale, are often recommended due to their balanced profile and moderate bitterness, which can cut through the dish's richness without overpowering it. These beers typically have a toasty, caramel undertone that pairs well with the pie's crust and savory filling. Another excellent option is a porter or stout. These darker beers, with their roasted malt flavors and hints of chocolate or coffee, add depth and complexity to the dish, enhancing the beefy flavors of the steak and ale pie. For those preferring something with a bit more hop character, an English IPA can also work well, offering a slightly more pronounced bitterness that can cleanse the palate between bites. Ultimately, the best beer for steak and ale pies is one that harmonizes with the dish's flavors, elevating the dining experience while respecting the traditional comfort of this classic meal.

Other beer and stout options for your steak and ale pie

For American chefs attempting to recreate the traditional steak and ale pie, finding mild English dark brown ales can be a challenge in the U.S. However, a well-stocked liquor store may carry Samuel Smith's Nut Brown Ale, which is a solid choice. If you can't find a genuine English ale, consider using an American beer with a similar flavor profile, such as Samuel Adams Brown Ale or Yuengling Black & Tan. If your options are limited, seek out a flavorful dark or caramel-colored ale with a rich taste. Remember, if the beer lacks flavor, your pie will too.

While Irish beef stew is commonly made with Guinness—the most popular beer in the U.S.—the use of this renowned Irish dry stout in steak and ale pie can be somewhat contentious. Some tasters believe that the resulting sauce can be too bitter, overshadowing the delicate, slowly developed flavors of the meat. Other chefs, including English chef Jamie Oliver, argue that either a stout or a dark ale can work effectively. Ultimately, if you want to closely replicate the experience of enjoying this dish at a pub after a long day of walking, a dark British ale is your best option. However, if you prefer Guinness and it suits your palate, it can certainly complement your steak and ale pie.

What's The Best Beer For Steak And Ale Pies?

Other beer and stout options for your steak and ale pie

Recommended

Next up