master-cooks | Why Apple Pie And Cheddar Cheese Is Such An Iconic Pairing

The pairing of apple pie and cheddar cheese is a beloved culinary tradition that dates back centuries, blending flavors and textures in a way that delights the palate. This iconic duo is rooted in the early European settlers' customs, particularly from England, where cheese was commonly served with fruit-based desserts. The practice migrated to America, where it found a natural home with the classic apple pie. The combination of sweet and savory elements is what makes this pairing so irresistible. The sweetness and tartness of the apples contrast beautifully with the rich, sharp, and slightly salty flavor of cheddar cheese. Additionally, the creamy texture of the cheese complements the flaky crust of the pie, creating a harmonious balance. This culinary fusion not only satisfies the taste buds but also offers a unique sensory experience, making it a cherished tradition in many American households. Over time, this pairing has transcended regional boundaries and become a symbol of comfort food, celebrated for its simplicity and nostalgia. Whether served as a topping, a side, or melted directly over a slice of pie, cheddar cheese enhances the flavors of apple pie, elevating it to an iconic status in the world of desserts.

It's both tradition and a law

During the 17th and 18th centuries, English chefs frequently enhanced their pies with various sauces. It was the English who first paired Wensleydale cheese with apple pie. Over time, this regional cheese was largely replaced by cheddar, especially as people began to settle in New England.

The shift to cheddar occurred because it was more accessible in the United States compared to Wensleydale. The popularity of this dish in the North and Midwest, as opposed to the South, can largely be attributed to the abundance of dairy in those areas. In simpler terms, the regions where this combination thrives have a high population of cows, resulting in a plentiful supply of quality cheddar cheese.

While some may still find the pairing unusual, in the areas where it is enjoyed, serving apple pie with cheddar cheese is completely normal. For instance, Vermont enacted a law in 1999 addressing this very topic. The legislation requires apple pie vendors in the Green Mountain State to make a "good faith effort" to provide a serving of apple pie accompanied by one or more dairy options, including "a slice of cheddar cheese weighing at least ½ ounce."

Why Apple Pie And Cheddar Cheese Is Such An Iconic Pairing

It's both tradition and a law

Recommended

Next up