master-cooks | Shaken Vs Stirred: What's Right For Your Cocktail?

The debate over whether to shake or stir a cocktail is central to crafting the perfect drink, each method offering distinct effects on the cocktail’s texture and flavor. Shaking is typically reserved for cocktails that include fruit juices, dairy, or egg whites. This vigorous method thoroughly incorporates the ingredients and introduces air, resulting in a frothy, well-chilled drink with a slightly cloudy appearance. The rapid motion of shaking also helps to break down ingredients like citrus, enhancing their flavors and creating a more balanced drink. On the other hand, stirring is preferred for cocktails composed entirely of spirits, such as martinis and Manhattans. This gentler method allows the ingredients to blend harmoniously without over-diluting the drink. Stirring maintains the clarity and smoothness of the cocktail, ensuring a silky texture and subtly blending the flavors. The process is performed with a bar spoon in a mixing glass, carefully chilling the drink while minimizing aeration. Ultimately, the choice between shaking and stirring depends on the cocktail’s ingredients and the desired outcome. For a lively, refreshing drink with a frothy finish, shaking is the way to go. For a more refined, spirit-forward experience, stirring is ideal. Understanding these techniques allows bartenders and enthusiasts alike to create the perfect cocktail for any occasion.

When to shake your cocktail

The cocktail shaker has been a staple since the mid-19th century, continuing to be the bartender's preferred tool for mixing drinks. While some may argue it's overused, when crafting a cocktail with multiple ingredients, a shaker is undoubtedly the best option. Alcohol and components like citrus or cream don’t blend easily and require a technique that ensures they remain mixed in the glass while harmonizing the various flavors. Shaking also introduces air into the mixture, resulting in a lighter drink with a frothy top, and cools it down in a way that other methods simply can't achieve.

Grab a shaker and try our ideal margarita recipe, which features quality tequila, Cointreau, fresh lime, and agave for a perfectly balanced summer classic. Other popular cocktails that benefit from shaking include White Russians, cosmopolitans, and the French martini (the only martini that should be shaken due to its inclusion of pineapple juice).

When to stir your cocktail

Cocktails primarily consist of various types of alcohol, such as the previously mentioned Negroni, which features gin. For an ideal Negroni, we suggest opting for a robust gin, particularly one with a strong juniper flavor, along with Campari and sweet vermouth. Since this drink is entirely alcohol-based, all you need to do is stir the ingredients with ice using a bar spoon. This method results in a smooth and velvety drinking experience. However, be cautious—the Negroni can be quite potent, especially since stirring doesn't dilute the alcohol as much as shaking would.

Other popular cocktails that are typically stirred include the Manhattan, the old-fashioned, and the boulevardier. What about muddled drinks like the mint julep? Depending on the number and type of ingredients, it’s best to stir this cocktail as well, since it mainly consists of bourbon, with mint and simple syrup as the only additional components. Now that you understand when to shake and when to stir a cocktail, feel free to discuss this with your favorite bartender. We’re sure they’ll have their own insights on the matter.

Shaken Vs Stirred: What's Right For Your Cocktail?

When to shake your cocktail

When to stir your cocktail

Recommended

Next up